He also ordered Cartwright should pay pounds 200 costs.
Cartwright will now face trial in December after denying three charges of breaching the Asbo.
Jobless Mrs Cartwright used Article 8 of the Human Rights Act to argue she had a right to "respect for her private and family life".
He also ordered that Mrs Cartwright, who is now living in a bail hostel in Sunderland, should pay pounds 200 costs towards the appeal hearing.
also says that she cannot have sex without making the noise and has also asked a sexual psychologist vouch for her in court.
During the four-day preliminary hearing, Deputy District Attorney Ardith Javan argued that Cartwright
lacked the mental capacity to remarry, to manage her finances and to make health care decisions for herself.
Now, the Cartwright
family have been sent to prison by a judge at York Crown Court.
When a neighbor heard feeble cries for help 10 months ago from the old Cartwright
Motel in Val Verde, she found a sickly Mary Cartwright
, 80, injured from a fall.
The four-year order was imposed on April 17 and prevented Cartwright
"making excessive noise".
The four-year order was imposed by magistrates in Sunderland on April 17 and prevented Cartwright
"making excessive noise" anywhere in England.
, whose husband sat in the public gallery, elected to be tried by jury and the case will be transferred to Newcastle Crown Court at a later date.
Timothy Watkins, who was living in his car when he met Cartwright
, soon was driving a new BMW and a truck, and having a swimming pool built.