Critical Realism


Also found in: Wikipedia.

Critical Realism

 

a trend, or method, in realistic literature and art in the 19th and 20th centuries. The concept of critical realism was adopted by Soviet literary and art criticism from M. Gorky, who used the expression “critical realism” in 1934 to describe the stress on expose in realistic literature of the 19th century. However, the revelatory themes by no means exclude an element of reaffirmation in the realistic art of the 19th and 20th centuries.

REFERENCES

Lavretskii, A. “O sud’be odnogo literaturovedcheskogo termina.” Izv. AN SSSR: Otdelenie literatury i iazyka, 1957, vol. 16, no 1.
Nikolaev, P. “Realizm kak teoretiko-literaturnaia problema.” In Sovetskoe literaturovedenie za 50 let. Moscow, 1967.

Critical Realism

 

a trend in modern idealist philosophy that traces its origins back to the critical philosophy of Kant.

The principles that served as a point of departure for critical realism were formulated in Germany in the late 19th and early 20th century by A. Riehl, O. Kulpe, and A. Messer, among others. Critical realism was established as an independent school in the USA in 1920, when D. Drake, A. Lovejoy, D. Pratt, A. Rogers, G. Santayana, R. W. Sellars, and C. Strong published their Essays in Critical Realism, a detailed exposition of the doctrine of critical realism. The most essential part of the doctrine is its theory of cognition, in which critical realism opposes itself to new realism: whereas the latter considers the process of knowing the external world to be directly included in consciousness of the subject, to be “seized” by it as it is, critical realism assumes that the process of knowing is mediated by datum, or the content of consciousness.

The problem of the nature of the datum is resolved by critical realists variously. Pratt and Lovejoy identify it with perception. They believe that the datum to a certain extent presents the features of external reality, the knowledge of which allows the subject to orient himself in the world around him. Their views thus come close to the subjective idealist “theory of hieroglyphs.” Santayana, Drake, Strong, and Rogers look upon the datum as an abstract concept, the logical “essence” of a thing, which in the case of correct cognition can coincide with the real essence of the thing. Here ideal essences acquire an ontological character that leads to a new variant of Platonism. Sellars occupies a separate place: he identifies the datum with an adequate reflection in consciousness of the external world and is thus led to a materialist treatment of the process of cognition.

REFERENCES

Bogomolov, A. S. Anglo-amerikanskaia burzhuaznaia filosofiia epokhi imperializma. Moscow, 1964. Chapter 8.
Lukanov, D. M. Gnoseologiia amerikanskogo “realizma.” Moscow, 1968.
Iulina, N. S. “Kontseptsiia real’nosti v amerikanskom ’kriticheskom realizme’.” Filosofskie nauki, 1958, no. 2.
Hicks, G. D. Critical Realism. London, 1938.

D. M. LUKANOV

References in periodicals archive ?
In a context where conservative intellectuals in the United States and Canada are aggressively challenging the legitimacy of radical scholars promoting their political agendas in higher education, we find the rallying cry for a sociology defined exclusively around critical realism problematic.
1) The issue of mandatory influenza immunisation for nurses has ignored the intersection of social constructionism and critical realism regarding the concrete, objective presentation of science and nurses' epistemological and ontological realities.
The contributors to this very well-integrated collection explore these urgent questions from a wide range of perspectives, including sociological analysis based in critical realism and personal reflexivity studies, the ethics of global warming, African traditions, feminist perspectives of care, patristic and Thomistic insights, and the ethics of individual responsibility.
There are two types of realism, First; Western realism that is also said as critical realism and it arose after the French Revolution.
Critical realism is a research approach that acknowledges the role of process in sociology and that evidence is essential but open to fluctuation and individual interpretation, this values the mechanics of systems and structures in conjunction with the potential for human intervention and change.
In this article, we describe a research platform for initial teacher education, developed by the Project RITE (Rethinking Initial Teacher Education) (1) research team, which combines key ideas from complexity theory and critical realism (CT-CR) and applies these to teacher education.
She outlines the international and historical higher education context and contemporary movements in student learning research; the theories of critical realism, the concepts of Archer, a realist perspective on knowledge and curriculum, and how these theories can be drawn together to focus on the development of student agency; her research and the data in terms of student choice to study engineering, the experience of being an engineering student, engagement with peers and educators, and engagement with studies; and the potential significance of this information for student learning and change in the engineering education and higher education systems.
In the chapter on postmodernity Hiebert articulates his concern for a critical realism in which "human knowledge is based on critical engagement with the world rather than a distant magisterial, management explanation of it (positivism) or personal knowledge limited to particular situations (instrumentalism)" (p.
The defense of a critical realism is thereby set in motion.
Significantly, the letter appeared in the same issue of Landfall as 'Fiction and the Social Pattern: Some Implications of Recent New Zealand Writing', Robert Chapman's analysis of the continuing tradition of critical realism in the fiction of 1946 through 1951.
With the publication, in 2000, of From East to West, however, Bhaskar has distanced himself from orthodox critical realism (which has affinities with a realist philosophy of science and materialist dialectics).
Chapter topics discuss information research management with regards to IT- reliant systems, a management control system, critical realism regarding the implementation of automated performance management systems, cost estimation of lead system integrator engineering activities, the mixing of soft systems methodology and Unified Modeling Language in business process modeling, the examination of online purchase intentions in B2C e-commerce, and a research agenda for investigating open source software user communities, among others.

Full browser ?