Professional judgment should be used to determine whether the group
auditor is able to rely on the component
auditor's work.
Professional skepticism, which assures that an
auditor maintains independence, consists of making an independent determination of how the same transactions should be recorded in the company's records.
Participants were asked to respond, on a scale from 1 (disagree) to 10 (agree), whether they had experienced variation in IT
auditor competence.
But SOX mandates have modified the relationship between external
auditors, firms, and firm managers.
The Institute of Chartered Accountants of England and Wales (ICAEW) comment letter calls for a "fundamental change in implementation approach," stating, "the crux of the issue is that management should not be remade in the image of the regulators and
auditors ...
Organizational independence does mean that if decisions are made that the Naval Audit Service considers to be inappropriate or unfair, the
auditor general can challenge them with the secretary and under secretary of the Navy--and has done so successfully on occasion.
For more tips on preparing for a third-party audit, including getting to know your
auditor, visit www.RecyclingToday.com.
SAS 104 replaces the above with "while exercising due professional care, the
auditor must plan and perform the audit to obtain sufficient appropriate evidence so that audit risk will be limited to a low level...." (emphasis added).
The PCAOB modified proposed rules it issued in December 2004 to require
auditors seeking preapproval to instead provide audit committees a description of the proposed services, rather than the actual engagement letters.
There remain many other hotly contested legal issues on the EU Commission's list, including audit committee requirements,
auditor independence, loans to directors and executive officers, certification of financial reports, and certification of internal control systems.
Oates and Goelzer's views and demonstrate that Congress intended not to reject, but to adopt, the definitional guidance set forth in the SEC's 2000
auditor independence rule--including the rule's definitional exceptions for tax services.