Enlightened Absolutism

(redirected from Benevolent Despotism)
The following article is from The Great Soviet Encyclopedia (1979). It might be outdated or ideologically biased.

Enlightened Absolutism

 

in several European absolutist states in the second half of the 18th century, a policy that pursued the ideas of the Enlightenment. The policy of enlightened absolutism entailed the implementation of reforms that abolished the most obsolete feudal institutions and that sometimes resulted in progress toward the development of bourgeois society.

In the 18th century, many representatives of the Enlightenment, including Voltaire, advocated the idea of a state headed by an “enlightened monarch” who would be capable of transforming public life on the basis of new, rational principles. With the fragmentation of feudalism, the maturation of the capitalist structure, and the spread of Enlightenment ideas, even the European monarchs were forced to consider making reforms. In a number of countries, feudal monopolies and some of the privileges of certain social estates were abolished, and peasant reforms were carried out. Ecclesiastical reforms were implemented (the subordination of the church to the state, the secularization of church lands, the expulsion of the Jesuits, and the elimination of monastic orders). School instruction and court and legal proceedings were reformed, and there was progress toward religious toleration and the relaxation of censorship. State policies sometimes reflected the ideas of the Physiocrats.

Reforms in the spirit of enlightened absolutism were carried out in a number of countries, including Prussia (during the early reign of Frederick II), Austria (beginning with the reign of Maria Theresa, and especially during the reign of Joseph II), Spain (under Charles III and the Enlightenment thinkers and statesmen P. Abarco de Bolea [the count of Aranda], P. Campomanes, and J. Moñino de Floridablanca), and Portugal (under S. J. de Carvalho, the marquis of Pombal). Enlightened absolutism was also characteristic of Denmark (under the ministers A. Bernstorff and J. F. Struensee, as well as the regent, Prince Frederick), Sweden (Gustavus III), and Russia (Catherine II’s policies during the 1760’s).

Some of the reforms associated with enlightened absolutism contributed objectively to the development of the capitalist structure, but feudal despotism prevailed in the policies of the enlightened sovereigns. The incompatibility between Enlightenment principles and absolutist regimes was most sharply manifested in Prussia under Frederick II. When the feudal absolutist state undertook reforms that infringed on the interests of the nobility, and especially when the reforms assumed a distinctly bourgeois character (for example, A. R. J. Turgot’s reforms of 1774–76 in France), feudal circles expressed resolute opposition, and ultimately the reforms were not implemented.

In general, the policy of enlightened absolutism was successful only in countries where the bourgeoisie was in a comparatively early stage of development. Even in these countries, the period of enlightened absolutism was brief. With the collapse of the feudal absolutist system as a result of the French Revolution, European monarchs abandoned their “liberal” undertakings in the spirit of enlightened absolutism. Almost everywhere the policy of enlightened absolutism gave way to open feudal reaction. In Russia the turning point was the suppression of the Peasant War under the leadership of E. I. Pugachev (1773–75).

REFERENCES

Mittenzwei, J. “Über das Problem des aufgeklärten Absolutismus.” Zeitschrift fur Geschichtswissenschaft, 1970, no. 9.
Druzhinin, N. M. “Prosveshchennyi absoliutizm v Rossii.” In the collection Absoliutizm v Rossii (XVII-XVIII vv.). Moscow, 1964.
The Great Soviet Encyclopedia, 3rd Edition (1970-1979). © 2010 The Gale Group, Inc. All rights reserved.
References in classic literature ?
It has been said that a benevolent despotism is the best possible form of government.
If not for the resistance there would be absolute power and the leader could drift into the realm of benevolent despotism. And if not for the resistance of someone's desire to 'rather do it this way' new ideas might not be tested and be accepted.
"I believe in a benevolent despotism. I am a despot.
On the bottom half, I'm the Tin Man" Actress Liza Minnelli, who has had new hips, a replacement knee and other surgical pins "I am the bionic woman" Veteran actress Angela Lansbury, pictured, 86, when asked if she got tired "London is wonderful, especially if you like steak and kidney pie" Hollywood star Kristen Stewart "I believe in a benevolent despotism. I am a despot.
If I thought Tony Blair would ever let us have a vote on it, for example such as is required on the European Constitution, I would be the first to put my X down in the 'all for it' box, but while democracy is a nice cuddly word, all fluffy and soft and smelling of fabric softener, it's not a great way to run things on a day-to-day basisThat's where I become an even bigger fan of benevolent despotism.
One early online community, for example, is traced from benevolent despotism to anarchy and back.
At more or less the same time, she met Lilian Baylis, who was running with benevolent despotism the Old Vic Theatre and, later, the newly built Sadler's Wells Theatre.
Moving the amendment calling for a delay, Donald Gorrie accused Dewar of "benevolent despotism" by taking the decision on his own.
With those perspectives and experiences firmly imbedded into our personal and national psyche, it is not hard to see how generous protectivism may merge easily with benevolent despotism. Indeed, as the twentieth century comes to a close, our understanding of authoritarianism suggests that the atrocities of many a dictator may well be connected at least in part with corrupted [and corrosive] versions of that combination.
Their ideological servants are already talking about the need to end the era of "benevolent despotism" and to eliminate the "democratic deficit." As if one could combine Maastricht with democracy from below, and the reign of capitalism with people taking their destiny into their own hands.
While one might perceive this as benevolent despotism, it did not prevent her from structuring a festival that epitomized the American slogan, E pluribus unum, and set a substantial pattern for future events.