appeal

(redirected from appealability)
Also found in: Dictionary, Thesaurus, Medical, Legal, Financial, Idioms.

appeal,

in law, hearing by a superior court to consider correcting or reversing the judgment of an inferior court, because of errors allegedly committed by the inferior court. The party appealing the decision is known as the appellant, the party who has won the case in the lower court as the appellee. The term is also sometimes used to describe the review by a court of the action of a government board or administrative officer. Appellate procedure is set by statute. There are two types of errors, of fact and of law. An error of fact is drawing a false inference from evidence presented at the trial. An error of law is an erroneous determination of the legal rules governing procedureprocedure,
in law, the rules that govern the obtaining of legal redress. This article deals only with civil procedure in Anglo-American law (for criminal procedure, see criminal law).
..... Click the link for more information.
, evidenceevidence,
in law, material submitted to a judge or a judicial body to resolve disputed questions of fact. The rules discussed in this article were developed in England for use in jury trials.
..... Click the link for more information.
, or the matters at issue between the parties. Ordinarily, only errors of law may be reviewed in appeal. In an appeal from an action tried in equityequity,
principles of justice originally developed by the English chancellor. In Anglo-American jurisprudence equitable principles and remedies are distinguished from the older system that the common law courts evolved.
..... Click the link for more information.
, however, the appellate court passes on the entire record, both as to facts and law. Should the appeals court conclude that no error was committed, it will affirm the decision of the lower court. If it finds that there was error, it may direct a retrial or grant a judgmentjudgment,
decision of a court of law respecting the issues before it. The term ordinarily is not applied to the decree (order) of courts of equity. The outstanding characteristic of a legal judgment, in contrast to an equitable decree, is its finality and fixity; thus, except
..... Click the link for more information.
 or decreedecree,
in law, decision of a suit in a court of equity. It is the counterpart in equity of the judgment in a court of law, although in those jurisdictions where law and equity have merged, judgment is sometimes used to include both.
..... Click the link for more information.
 in favor of the party who lost in the lower court. The determinations of appeals courts are usually printed, often with an opinion indicating the basis for the court's decisions. Such opinions are of great utility in guiding the inferior courts and are often cited as precedents in future cases. See also habeas corpushabeas corpus
[Lat.,=you should have the body], writ directed by a judge to some person who is detaining another, commanding him to bring the body of the person in his custody at a specified time to a specified place for a specified purpose.
..... Click the link for more information.
.

Appeal

 

(juridical), one of the forms of appealing judicial decisions that have not become res judicata in criminal and civil proceedings.

In the appeal procedure, the next higher court examines the merits of the decision of a lower court, reviewing anew the investigation of the evidence presented in the case and any new evidence that may be presented. After this, the higher court will either affirm the appealed decision or, having reversed it, will render a new decision. This distinguishes an appeal from a cassation, which means in bourgeois states that a higher court cannot render a new decision but can only cancel the appealed decision or direct the lower court to retry the case. In an appeal, a court’s decision is reviewed not merely in terms of isolated procedures but on the merit of the case as a whole—including the guilt or innocence of the defendant, the punitive measure, the recovery or dismissal, and the amount sought in the suit. The decision resulting from an appeal procedure is usually subject to a cassation appeal (with a few exceptions).

The appeal form developed in France during the period of the consolidation of absolutism, since an appeal made it possible to transfer a case from the courts of the local feudal lords to royal courts. In bourgeois states, as a rule, all judicial decisions can be appealed, aside from jury trials and such exceptions as court-martials. Only in Great Britain, by a law passed in 1907, are appeals of jury verdicts allowed. Moreover, in reviewing a case, the appellate court has the right to make worse the position of the parties—for example, by increasing the punitive measure. The introduction of appeals of decisions arising out of jury trials in Great Britain was a departure even from the bourgeois-democratic foundations of the judicial process, since the jury trial in bourgeois countries is the sole form of the general population’s participation in administration of justice. Under an appeal system, the center of proceedings is shifted to the appellate court. This essentially limits the importance of the courts of first instance, which are usually more accessible to the population from the point of view of publicity of the judicial proceedings.

In the USSR, the appeal procedure was abolished by the First Decree on the Courts of Nov. 22, 1917, since it was regarded as an institution that could not be conducive to the consolidation of the authority of the new people’s courts. In contemporary Soviet procedure there are only isolated elements of appeal procedure. For example, article 46 of the Fundamentals of Civil Procedure of the USSR and the Union Republics (1961) allows the next higher court to render a new decision if the case requires no gathering or additional checking of evidence and the circumstances of the case were fully and correctly established by the court of first instance but some error in applying the law has occurred. Such a formulation does not undermine the authority and importance of decisions rendered by lower courts, primarily by raion or city people’s courts—the basic units of the Soviet judicial system. The form of appealing court decisions in the USSR is that of cassation.

T. N. DOBROVOL’SKAIA.

appeal

1. Law
a. the judicial review by a superior court of the decision of a lower tribunal
b. a request for such review
c. the right to such review
2. Cricket a verbal request to the umpire from one or more members of the fielding side to declare a batsman out
3. English law (formerly) a formal charge or accusation
References in periodicals archive ?
Immediate appealability can also increase the predictability of the specific types of transnational cases that should not proceed in a U.S.
The court discussed how there was only instance in which the Supreme Court directly addressed the appealability of a district court's order for sanctions, in which the Court found jurisdiction did not exist.
The Agency argues that Congress' awareness of the one-way appealability rule when it made compensatory damages available in the Civil Rights Act of 1991 means Congress, in conditioning the waiver of sovereign immunity on an agency having a right to a jury trial, must have recognized that an agency would be unable to exercise its right to a jury trial if compensatory damages were awarded in the administrative process.
[section] 7513(d) as to appealability under [section] 7701.
(172) The district court did, however, grant Patterson a certificate of appealability ("COA") on the issues of his competence to stand trial and ineffectiveness of counsel at the guilt-innocent and sentencing phases of the trial.
Then, Gilles asked, "if more and more arbitrators say 'let's do a class arbitration'--which it's in their self-interest to do, because they make tons of money with these classes--will companies decide that it's one thing to decide in court with the rules of evidence and appealability, and it's a whole other thing to do it in this private, slightly crazy world where the rules of evidence don't apply?"
Traditionally, finality was linked to appealability, such that "finality was identified for purposes of preclusion in much the same way as it was identified for purposes of appeal." (90) More recently, however, courts have expanded the definition of "finality," indicating that "preclusion may be appropriate if the order is sufficiently firm." (91) In Lummus Co.
To the contrary, Sylvester did not address the appealability of the bonding order because its decision only required the district court to reconsider the amount of the bond on remand.
The labyrinth of disputed procedural issues in Medellin includes the standards under the habeas statute for granting a certificate of appealability (COA) and whether the Court should stay or dismiss the case in light of the President's memorandum.
LEGAL COMMENTARY: The court first addressed the plaintiffs argument that TUH's appeal was not properly before the court because "the question of appealability implicates the jurisdiction of the court." Conversely, TUH argued that even though the order, which was the subject matter from which it took its appeal, was not a final order, the discovery order at issue was appealable because of the "Collateral Order Rule." It argued that rule "permits an appeal as a right from a non-final order if it is separable from and collateral to the main action, involves a right too important to be denied review, and if the review if postponed, the right will be irreparably lost." However, the court noted that the collateral order rule must be interpreted narrowly.
Although Yohn granted the defense a certification of appealability on the jury selection issue, Abu-Jamal's attorneys for at least eight months failed to notice the errors and have yet to file any appeal based upon them.