"All variations of the [alternate] encounter theory assume that matter was torn out of the sun by a passing star.
Lyman Spitzer, Jr., then at Yale University, was explaining his own refutation of the encounter theory. Current thinking has seesawed back to a refined version of the nebular hypothesis.
The forensic report in Ishrat Jahan encounter case strengthens the Central Bureau of Investigation's (CBI's) case against the accused police officers of Gujarat as it points out glaring discrepancies in the encounter theory
On Monday, metropolitan magistrate Tamang's reports raised doubts on the veracity of the encounter theory
. He claimed that the four were picked up illegally by the Gujarat Police from Mumbai and killed on June 14.
Giving a clean chit to federal Minister for Minority Affairs, Abdul Rahman Antulay, over raising some questions on the encounter theory
, Vinita said "I don't blame Antulay for asking such questions because an impression was being created that the trio acted impulsively."