the Sublime

(redirected from sublime, the)

Sublime, the

 

an aesthetic category characterizing the inner significance of objects and phenomena and revealing a discrepancy between their high ideal content and the real forms of their expression.

The concept of the sublime arose at the dawn of antiquity. The sublime characterized a special style of oratorical speech, as shown, for example, in the treatise by Pseudo-Longinus On the Sublime, dating from the first century A.D. (Russian translation, 1826). This meaning of the term was retained until the Renaissance. In classicism N. Boileau, C. Batteux, and others developed a doctrine of “high” and “low” styles of literature. As an independent aesthetic concept the sublime was first worked out in E. Burke’s treatise A Philosophical Inquiry Into the Origin of Our Ideas of the Sublime and the Beautiful (1757). Burke links the sublime to man’s innate feeling of self-preservation and sees the source of the sublime in all that “in one way or another is capable of evoking the idea of suffering or danger, that is, all that which, in one way or another, is full of dread” (Istoriia estetiki, vol. 2, Moscow, 1964, p. 103).

I. Kant in his Critique of Judgment (1790) provided a systematic analysis of the dichotomy between the beautiful and the sublime (Soch., vol. 5, Moscow, 1966, pp. 249-88). If the beautiful is characterized by a definite form and limited nature, then the essence of the sublime lies in its limitless, infinite grandeur and its incommensurability with the human capacity for contemplation and imagination. The sublime reveals the dual nature of man: it overwhelms him as a physical being and compels him to acknowledge his own finite and limited nature; at the same time, however, it exalts him as a spiritual being and awakens in him the ideas of reason and the awareness of his moral superiority even over nature, which is physically incommensurate and overpowering. Because of its moral character and its connections with the idea of freedom, Kant places the sublime above the beautiful. J. F. Schiller, developing these Kantian ideas in On the Sublime (1792), speaks of the sublime not only in nature but also in history. Subsequently, Schiller overcomes the Kantian dichotomy of the beautiful and the sublime by introducing the unifying concept of the ideally beautiful.

In the further development of German aesthetics the emphasis in the interpretation of the sublime was shifted from the perception of it to the correlation between idea and form, or between what is expressed and its means of expression. J. P. Richter defined the sublime as infinity conceived in relation to a sense object (Vorschule der Asthetik, Hamburg, 1804), and F. W. Schelling defined it as the embodiment of the infinite in the finite. For K. Solger the sublime is an idea that is not yet fully manifest and that is still “to be disclosed” (Vorlesungen uber Aesthetik, Leipzig, 1829, pp. 242-43). For Hegel it is the disparity between an individual phenomenon and the infinite idea expressed by it.

Marxist aesthetics does not set up a dichotomy between the sublime and the beautiful, and it considers the sublime in close connection with heroism, with the ardor of struggle and of the creative activity of the masses. The sublime is inseparable from the ideas of man’s greatness and dignity. In this it is akin to the tragic, which is a special form of sublime ardor.

REFERENCES

Chernyshevskii, N. G. “Vozvyshennoe i komicheskoe.” In Izbr. filosofskie sochineniia, vol. 1. Moscow, 1950. Pages 252-99.
Borev, lu. B. Kategorii estetiki. Moscow, 1959. Chapter 2.
Kagan, M. S.Lektsiipo marksistko-leninskoi estetike, part 1. Lenin-grad, 1963. Pages 69-88.
Seidl, A. Zur Geschichte des Erhabenheitsbegriffes seit Kant. Leipzig, 1889.
Hippie, W. J. The Beautiful, the Sublime, the Picturesque in Eighteenth-Century British Aesthetic Theory. Carbondale, Ill., 1957.
Monk, S. H. The Sublime . . . [2nd ed.]. Ann Arbor, Mich., 1960.

V. V. ZUBOV

References in periodicals archive ?
For Sublime, the smart money goes into investing in differentiation and the technology and moats associated with it that keep potential competition at arm's length because making competing products is extremely difficult.
30 -- The first time I heard Sublime, the band had already broken up and its talented lead singer, driving force and the man who can be credited for the band, its sound, and its essence, Brad Nowell, was already dead.
In that sense, even though Kant accepts in his earlier works that, through the experience of the sublime, the movements of the mind or emotions are stimulated essentially by motion (phusis) or the moving movedness of nature, in the third Critique, he upholds intellectual purposiveness and its ultimate indirect relation to the supersensible as the primary criterion for an experience or presentation to be judged sublime beyond human virtues, religious values and social/communal interests.
Again as with Burke's sublime, the subject fears the object abstractedly and from a position of actual safety: Bold, overhanging, as it were threatening cliffs, thunder clouds towering up into the heavens, bringing with them flashes of lightning and crashes of thunder, volcanoes with their all-destroying violence, hurricanes with the devastation they leave behind, the boundless ocean set into a rage, a lofty waterfall on a mighty river, etc., make our capacity to resist into an insignificant trifle in comparison with their power.
The issue then becomes how we might utilise the attempts to represent the sublime, the senses conveyed in these representations, and the cultural attitudes towards these two, to better understand the function of the ethical and the moral, as well as meaning itself.
The technological sublime, the human ability to exceed limitations of nature, has reached its logical end.
Although the eighteenth-century's emphasis on reason traditionally placed man above the sublime, the Gothic is the realm of fantasy, repression, and the imagination--rationality is impotent.
My goal here is not to censor but rather to raise a red flag of warning lest such terms as the sublime, the ineffable, the unpresentable, the uncanny, and immanence mask sedimented gender binaries that will keep the feminine in the ground along with the beautiful.
Kant has observed, that the understanding is sublime, the imagination beautiful--yet it is evident, that poets, and men who undoubtedly possess the liveliest imaginations, are most touched by the sublime" (5:275).
"Sublime, the Unclear." "The Most Sublime Act:" Essays on the Sublime.
In her analysis of Louisa Musgrove's fall on the Cobb at Lyme, Clark discusses Austen's objections to the cult of the sublime, the main two being the safe risk of death and the aesthetic enjoyment of a such a scene.
The Gothic sublime dramatizes Schopenhauer's oceanic sublime, the desire to return to "the inviting tranquillity of death,"(21) desire that Pym appears to experience: [In the Gothic] the metaphysics of human superiority espoused by Kant are no longer the conditions of the sublime.